King Diocletian
Magistrate
I will get back to State of Emergency, but this is a sort of palate-cleanser inspired by the thread on judicial punishments.
“She said what?”
The bishop was furious, his face beetroot and the wart at the end of his nose seeming almost to glow.
Sir Thomas took a deep breath. “She said, your grace, that indulgences were an abomination lacking scriptural precedent foisted upon defenceless people by a church that was institutionally corrupt.”
“Abomination? Institutionally corrupt?” He wondered if a wart could burst with anger.
“She also said that the system of tithes was punitive and arbitrarily applied and called for a thorough review of the system of taxation.”
“She’s mad. And she must be stopped. What, Thomas, are we going to do?”
Sir Thomas didn’t know what they were going to do. Nobody knew what they were going to do. The situation was unprecedented. Lady Isabel was 22, beautiful and intelligent. People loved her. She spoke to them and heard their concerns. She sympathised and, if she felt strongly enough, she articulated their problems. She’d spoken out against excessive taxation to fund wars in France. She’d queried whether town money really should be spent on renovating the merchants’ guild-hall. She wasn’t naïve; she didn’t take up every cause; but when she did she spoke clearly, simply and powerfully. She was popular and she was dangerous. And now she’d turned on the church.
*
Isabel drove her horse hard, relishing the wind on her face as her soft brown hair flowed behind her. She needed this. She needed the release. Should she have said that at the public meeting? Probably not, but it was true. This was how it always happened. She listened having vowed she’d say nothing and then she got annoyed with the flabby arguments of others and spoke up. Really she was just trying to clarify things, to move the debate along, but she would always end up making her feelings clear and suddenly there’d be a movement behind her, people urging her to lead protests and organise opposition.
And now of course the people would come to her with petitions. It was tiring but she knew it was work she had to do. She was lucky: she as high-born and this was something she could do to help others. And it was necessary now. Her father, she knew, would have stood up for the people – he had stood up for the people – but now he was ill and weak and confined to bed and her stepmother seemed concerned only with lavish banquets and fine clothing and jewellery.
They’d never got on, but eight years after her mother’s death, five years after her father had remarried, she’d got used to her, accepted she would always be there, always be demanding more. The issue was more pressing now, of course, with her father so sick. That was why the taxes had become an issue, why she’d spoken out against a new levy that, she knew, was largely going to pay off debts accrued by her stepmother’s extravagant lifestyle.
Isabel came to the forest and slowed to a trot. It was cool under the branches and frost still lay in shaded patches. She pulled her cloak tighter around herself. This church business was absurd. She was fortunate, of course; she could read the Latin, something she wasn’t sure Father William was capable of. This business of buying pardons seemed monstrous to her – there was nothing about that in the Bible. And the way they enforced the tithes, even when harvests were poor, as they had been last year, well, that seemed to her a betrayal of what Christianity was about. Wasn’t it about helping people, about protecting the needy, rather than about squeezing everybody to make sure the bishop could keep himself in fine wines from France?
She knew the church wouldn’t be happy but, really, it was dreadful the way William allowed the bishop to bully him. It was dreadful the way they used people’s terror of hell and the afterlife to fleece them in this one. The trees opened out and she looked down the valley, at the dark lake in the distance. She ran a hand through her hair, feeling the damp of sweat on her brow. She just wished she didn’t always have to be the one protecting the people, but she supposed with the advantages she’d had and her education it was her duty to do so. She came out into a meadow again and kicked hard back towards home.
*
Maude sat by the bed of her husband, watching the unsteady rise and fall of his chest. She had known, of course, that this was always likely when she married him, 18 years her senior; in fact, that had always been part of the plan. But the crisis was coming. He was dying, had only a few weeks left, and she needed to ensure that when he went she stayed on. She deserved it, after all: five years of enduring his impotent fumblings. But soon he would be gone and, after an appropriate time, she could marry Lord John with whom she’d been conducting a discreet affair since before she’d even married. Only one thing stood in her way: Isabel.
How she hated her. She was pretty and clever and popular, her slenderness a constant rebuke to how she’d allowed herself to put on a little weight. And worse than that, she would speak out about what she saw injustices. Maude thought of Isabel standing in the great hall, arguing passionately that the increased taxes were unjustifiable, failing to recognise that the money was necessary to maintain the prestige of her father’s house. She had to find a way of destroying her.
“She said what?”
The bishop was furious, his face beetroot and the wart at the end of his nose seeming almost to glow.
Sir Thomas took a deep breath. “She said, your grace, that indulgences were an abomination lacking scriptural precedent foisted upon defenceless people by a church that was institutionally corrupt.”
“Abomination? Institutionally corrupt?” He wondered if a wart could burst with anger.
“She also said that the system of tithes was punitive and arbitrarily applied and called for a thorough review of the system of taxation.”
“She’s mad. And she must be stopped. What, Thomas, are we going to do?”
Sir Thomas didn’t know what they were going to do. Nobody knew what they were going to do. The situation was unprecedented. Lady Isabel was 22, beautiful and intelligent. People loved her. She spoke to them and heard their concerns. She sympathised and, if she felt strongly enough, she articulated their problems. She’d spoken out against excessive taxation to fund wars in France. She’d queried whether town money really should be spent on renovating the merchants’ guild-hall. She wasn’t naïve; she didn’t take up every cause; but when she did she spoke clearly, simply and powerfully. She was popular and she was dangerous. And now she’d turned on the church.
*
Isabel drove her horse hard, relishing the wind on her face as her soft brown hair flowed behind her. She needed this. She needed the release. Should she have said that at the public meeting? Probably not, but it was true. This was how it always happened. She listened having vowed she’d say nothing and then she got annoyed with the flabby arguments of others and spoke up. Really she was just trying to clarify things, to move the debate along, but she would always end up making her feelings clear and suddenly there’d be a movement behind her, people urging her to lead protests and organise opposition.
And now of course the people would come to her with petitions. It was tiring but she knew it was work she had to do. She was lucky: she as high-born and this was something she could do to help others. And it was necessary now. Her father, she knew, would have stood up for the people – he had stood up for the people – but now he was ill and weak and confined to bed and her stepmother seemed concerned only with lavish banquets and fine clothing and jewellery.
They’d never got on, but eight years after her mother’s death, five years after her father had remarried, she’d got used to her, accepted she would always be there, always be demanding more. The issue was more pressing now, of course, with her father so sick. That was why the taxes had become an issue, why she’d spoken out against a new levy that, she knew, was largely going to pay off debts accrued by her stepmother’s extravagant lifestyle.
Isabel came to the forest and slowed to a trot. It was cool under the branches and frost still lay in shaded patches. She pulled her cloak tighter around herself. This church business was absurd. She was fortunate, of course; she could read the Latin, something she wasn’t sure Father William was capable of. This business of buying pardons seemed monstrous to her – there was nothing about that in the Bible. And the way they enforced the tithes, even when harvests were poor, as they had been last year, well, that seemed to her a betrayal of what Christianity was about. Wasn’t it about helping people, about protecting the needy, rather than about squeezing everybody to make sure the bishop could keep himself in fine wines from France?
She knew the church wouldn’t be happy but, really, it was dreadful the way William allowed the bishop to bully him. It was dreadful the way they used people’s terror of hell and the afterlife to fleece them in this one. The trees opened out and she looked down the valley, at the dark lake in the distance. She ran a hand through her hair, feeling the damp of sweat on her brow. She just wished she didn’t always have to be the one protecting the people, but she supposed with the advantages she’d had and her education it was her duty to do so. She came out into a meadow again and kicked hard back towards home.
*
Maude sat by the bed of her husband, watching the unsteady rise and fall of his chest. She had known, of course, that this was always likely when she married him, 18 years her senior; in fact, that had always been part of the plan. But the crisis was coming. He was dying, had only a few weeks left, and she needed to ensure that when he went she stayed on. She deserved it, after all: five years of enduring his impotent fumblings. But soon he would be gone and, after an appropriate time, she could marry Lord John with whom she’d been conducting a discreet affair since before she’d even married. Only one thing stood in her way: Isabel.
How she hated her. She was pretty and clever and popular, her slenderness a constant rebuke to how she’d allowed herself to put on a little weight. And worse than that, she would speak out about what she saw injustices. Maude thought of Isabel standing in the great hall, arguing passionately that the increased taxes were unjustifiable, failing to recognise that the money was necessary to maintain the prestige of her father’s house. She had to find a way of destroying her.