I'm fussy too, believe me, that's why i was disappointed by that scene in Hunter J ... i love a female whipping, cause i love how a woman body respond at every lash, i love how the body srch and the had goes up and down, i love the sweat after a long punishment, i love to see a woman torso stratched by the bound with arms over head and of course i love whipping marks, more reddish and bloody they are more i love them.
That's why i love Snidely comics, because he is (was) deeply into whipping, he draws lash after lash showing the reactions of the whipping, every single sufference at the impact of the whip on the sweated sken, sooo erotic
Of course Hunter J have modern drawings, more beautiful, i'd die to have a whipping comics with the quality of Hunter J, but unforyunately we have not such a beauty.
I'm italian and the author of Hunter J is italian i heard her talking at a Comic Concention and she talked about everything but the punishment, she is vanilla, even her fans are vanilla ... not so much emphasis on the punishment, if we will have another whipping scene we will be very lucky, trust me
But in the rare case i'm wrong, i think she can be masochist, she obviously identify herself with the protagonist, not the fat guy, maybe she secretly love to be a slave whipped daily in her deep and dark desires.